Well — Obama gave his acceptance speech for the democratic nomination last night. It was a pretty historic event — the first African American to ever be nominated for president. I didn’t actually watch the speech, instead choosing to do other things, but I did today on youtube. And if there is one think that is certain — should he be elected he would likely be the most regal president in modern history. He is by far the best speech giver of any politician I’ve seen: enthralling, inspiring, honest and to the point in many circumstances (typical political posturing not withstanding).
So what were my thoughts on it as a whole (since I’ve already been asked once and will probably be asked again)? I like Senator Obama. It’s hard not to, truth be told. And I agree with many of his policy decisions and choices (with a few notable exceptions). But will I vote for him? I don’t know yet. Here some quick thoughts about the speech that help move me, one way or the other to a decision on that.
I like that Obama is unafraid to speak to the current political situation. Voting for Bush the second time around is honestly one of the biggest regrets in my life and something that the Holy Spirit has used to intensely convict me in regards to my beliefs and understandings. The vision of change naturally, it follows, speaks to this as change is what I desire to see in our grand country.
Obama starts by speaking to the American promise, that every American, through hard work, can pursue their own dreams. He lays out how the current administration has threatened it intensely (by entering an unjust war, by allowing debt to pile, by creating an economic situation where markets are crashing all around us…) with their neoliberal economic policies. “We are a better country than this…We love this country to much to let the next 4 years look like the last 8,” he says (which gets a resounding “Amen!” from me). And the next 4 years (under McCain) would like the last 8. McCain’s primary economic advisor would like nothing more than to continue the process of shocking and destroying our economy (we are a nation “suffering from mental recession…a nation of whiners”). I’ll likely post more about this later but I just can’t in any way, shape or form stand behind the neoliberal methods of shock to completely reshape an economy. Not everything can (or should) be privatized (One of Bush’s most nefarious legacies will be the privatization of war but I digress; that is a discussion for another time).
Obama goes on to spell this out clearer, how our job market is rapidly in decline (with multinationals taking jobs where labor is cheap) and how new jobs aren’t being created (23 million were under Clinton) and how the average American income fell $2000 under Bush (it grew $7500 under Clinton). And then he lined out how he saw the government functioning in society, how it is to (broadly) “protect us from harm, provide a good education, keep our water clean and toys safe, invest in new schools, roads and science and technology” and ultimately be “for us not against us,” insuring opportunities for every American willing to work for them (and not just the rich and powerful).
Again — he is really a powerful orator. There are echos of Martin Luther King Jr in there (which he recalls specifically before the speech is done). But to this point he has yet to outline his platform in any grand sense of the word. We know what he doesn’t like about Washington currently but what change would he push upon election?
Taxes:
- A tax code that rewards businesses and workers NOT lobbyists.
- Stop tax breaks to companies who ship jobs over seas (instead doing the reverse).
- Eliminate capitol gain taxes for businesses and startups.
- Cut taxes for 95% of all working families (so as to not tax the middle class).
These points I honestly agree with. I think pushing our own economy forward specifically by enabling and rewarding job creation and innovation here is a grand idea. And while I’d prefer a 1 or 2% VAT tax on everything over an income tax OR a flat tax across the board with no breaks whatsoever on income I’d much prefer to see cuts come in such a way that encourages the middle class to be involved in the market and that does not put the load of the tax burden on their backs whilst simultaneously taking it off of the back of the wealthiest in the nation.
Energy:
- End dependence on oil from the middle east in 10 years.
- Invest in reneweable energy/reuseable fuels (wind, solar, bio) — thereby creating new industries and new jobs.
- clean cole/nuclear/natural gas/retool autos/
This is something I whole heartedly agree with. I can’t wait for the day when we have no dependence on oil. Truth be told — big oil actually owns patents that could completely get us off of it but its not lucrative to them to make use of them. That needs to change. I would love to see some actually lead out in this area and stimulate awareness. I think in many ways (regardless of what you think about him — I’m not a big fan by any means) Al Gore’s “An Inconvenient Truth” has been an excellent catalyst and we really need to take advantage of the situation. And it will likely take someone whose pockets aren’t lined with big oil money.
Education:
- Provide world class education for every child.
- Invest in early childhood education.
- Support teachers
- Higher standards and accountability
- College edu to all willing to serve country
Again, this is an area thats hard to disagree with. Public school education is good (but not sufficient). Privatizing it has proved mostly disastrous (as New Orleans post-Katrina attests to). It would be wonderful if this were an area a President was diligent in speaking to (particularly supporting teachers, and higher standards and accountability).
Health Care
- Affordable health care to every American.
- Lower premiums.
- Health care like congressmen have for those that don’t have it.
- No discrimination against those that are sick and NEED care.
I’m for socializing health care. In fact while Obama’s plan is probably better suited to make use of the existing infrastructure, I quite like the idea of a fully socialized health care (particularly after spending time in countries that have it and discussing it with their inhabitants). Regardless, I like a WHOLE lot that health care would be offered across the board to those that don’t get it/can’t afford it. Finally. Also, I’d love to see an end to corporate discrimination against those who are sick and in need. It breaks my heart to read of those with cancer and other diseases who could SURVIVE with proper treatment but are refused.
Random points:
- This would all cost money.
- Close corporate tax loopholes.
- Eliminate programs that don’t work and make those that do more efficient
This first point here fits in his tax plan. I’m not an accountant but it makes sense that close loopholes in the tax code would increase government revenue. The second point also makes a lot of sense (and is eerily like “limited/small government” of republicans of lore). Working for a state institution, I know a lot of programs “don’t work” and could easily be made much, much more efficient.
- Individual responsibility and mutual responsibility.
This is one of the best points I’ve heard a politician make (and one that almost makes me want to toss my vote his way). He spent several minutes talking about the need for individual responsibility and how Washington or a single politician could never be expected to do everything, that at some point mom’s and dad’s needed to stand up and turn off the TV’s and raise their kids, etc. WOW! Great, great points to be made, both inspiring and a-traditional (as far as politics are concerned).
Foreign Policy:
- Opposed war in Iraq from the start.
- Has voted for more troops in Afghanistan (including taking out Bin Laden) and wants to see the fight finished there.
- Time frame to remove troops from Iraq.
- Tough diplomacy with Russia and Iran.
- Build new alliances.
- Restore moral standing.
One of Obama’s strengths in this election is his foreign policy. It helps that he was adamantly against the unjust Iraq war. It helps that he understands that the Iraqi people want us out of there. And it helps that he is a non-interventionist (willing to take tough stands against Russia and Iran for example). This last point actually does bother me though. Being increasingly an advocate of non-violence, I found our quick attitude for intervention that precedes diplomacy troublesome. I like though that Obama is calling for diplomacy above…other…options. And I like that he recognizes a lot of our struggle with Islamic societies specifically and the rest of the world in general comes from how they view our moral standing as a nation (look to the NIE reports for the truth of this, as well as take some time to talk to people from other cultures). This
is important — much more important than a lot of people realize.
Obama also appeals to a common purpose transcending traditional political boundaries (democrat/republican agendas) which is helpful. He specifically appealed to the desire to see a reduction in the number of abortions in general, an upholding of the 2nd amendment whilst keeping AK-47’s off the streets and basic human rights for the gay and lesbian communities. I think these appeals are areas that are garnering him support from a much broader crowd than the democrats usually pick up (including many from evangelical circles). In fact one well known registered republican pastor (Joel Hunter) points to some of these ideals as being the way of pro-life politics going forward (see here).
My Conclusions
All that being said, the question still remains: vote for Obama or not? At this point McCain isn’t even an issue as I disagree with him on most everything. It’d take a complete renunciation of neoliberal economic theory and a foreign policy revision to get me to even consider him again (things I don’t foresee happening). And I love a lot of what Obama is saying. But I don’t love everything. For one I don’t like the messianic language that surrounds his campaign. He is not now, nor will he ever be my savior. It out right troubles me to see how people almost bow down in worship to him. One of the driving forces in this phenomena is his use of spiritual/otherly language in his campaign. There’s lot of “hope” and “transcending” talk as well as dabblings of “salvations.” Add to this biblical imagery like “a city on a hill” and you’ve got yourself in a tricky spot. While I’m not going to doubt or call into question his personal faith — it troubles me to see a man put himself into a place like this. It’s an ill-conceived notion and brings forth imagery of the Roman empire and a Caesar who was the salvation of his people (and who Jesus explicitly subverts with His very presence in this world). The continued escalation of this just turns me more and more away from his campaign.
Actually this last point really gets to the heart of where I’m at. It’s hard for me, at this time, to justify voting because I see myself as a citizen of the Kingdom of God and NOT of the US of A. Increasingly I see my social role as actually being the Kingdom before man (meaning actually living out its principles). This is something that no politician could actually get away with legislating because the power structure is so radically different, leaving an ambassador of Christ in the place of choosing between two different evils (whichever they perceive as the lesser). And as we all know — evil is as evil does. Anyways — this speaks to the dilemma I have and what I’m working through and towards. Actually there will probably be further posts about this in the future so don’t think I’m purposely skirting this issue. There is a LOT more I could say.
And, because this post is getting quite long, I’ll leave you with this: Obama calls us to “hold firmly without wavering to the hope that we confess (Hebrews 10:23)…” Do do this, but know what that hope is. It’s not the promise of America or Freedom or any president or leader but the hope of Christ and what He alone can offer.
* So as not to confuse folks to badly, I use the term neoliberal instead of neoconservative as it’s what the rest of the world calls such policy directions…